FAQs for Public review commenters
- What is the benefit of me participating in the IEEE SA Public Review process? What is the benefit for the IEEE?
- Are there costs associated with the Public Review?
- How do I access the draft?
- How are you notified of drafts available for Public Review?
- How do I submit my comments?
- Who do I contact if I have difficulties with the tool?
- Can I submit a comment outside the Public Review period?
- What if I miss the deadline?
- Am I able to share the draft with others?
- What can I expect with regard to responses to my comments?
- If I am a balloter, can I submit Public Review comments?
- What is the duration of Public Review?
- Do I have to have technical knowledge to submit comments?
- Where are my comments captured? Where do I find them?
- Can I edit or delete my comments once I enter them?
- How do I access my comments after the close of the Public Review period?
- Will I see comments from all Public Review participants, or just my own?
- Do I have to have technical knowledge to submit comments?
FAQs for Standards Committees/Delegates/Ballot Designees/Working Group Chairs
- What does IEEE SA Public Review mean?
- How does the Public Review process impact the existing process?
- What are the benefits of doing this?
- Does the public review commenter get a vote?
- Are the comments integrated into the myBallot system?
- Will this impact my ballot timeline?
- What are the requirements for reviewing/resolving comments?
- Do I have to take any additional notification steps?
- Can I reject comments?
- Do I have to send updated versions of the draft to a public review commenter?
- Can a public review commenter submit comments on an updated draft?
- Does Public Review occur throughout the life of the ballot?
- When and how is Public Review initiated (i.e., when does it begin)?
- How are Public Review comments established?
- Where are the comments captured? Where do I find them?
- Does the public review commenter have the right to appeal?
- When is a Working Group required to submit Public Review comments to RevCom?
- How do you upload Public Review comments as a part of a recirculation ballot?
- How do you upload Public Review comments as a part of the RevCom package?
- What is RevCom’s role in reviewing Public Review comments?
- Can Public Review comments delay the draft from being submitted to RevCom for approval?
- Can a recirculation ballot start while Public Review is still in progress?
- How long is a Public Review?
- Can I submit to RevCom if Public Review is still open?
- How do I identify Public Review comments from ballot comments in the Sponsor ballot?
- How do I download the Public Review comments?
- How do I respond to Public Review comments?
- What if the Working Group decides not to update the draft after considering all Public Review comments? Do I have to respond?
- Is failure to respond to a Public Review comment a reason for rejection/disapproval by RevCom?
- Will Public Review be a part of the RevCom package?
- Do Public Review comments affect the scope of a recirculation?
- Do balloters see all Public Review comments, or only those that result in a change to the draft?
- Am I required to send an updated draft if the response to Public Review comments did not identify that the draft will be updated?